Understanding the breaker scheme is important if you plan on designing a substation. Quite often, it is overwhelming to make sense of the entire scheme at a glance. Therefore, the figure below depicting a circuit breaker scheme will be used to simplify and explain various elements of the breaker’s design and its control.
Forms of Contact
Before explaining what each device in the scheme does, understanding the different forms of auxiliary contact is necessary. Every breaker comes fitted with an auxiliary switch. It is mechanically linked to the breaker’s trip-close mechanism. Within the auxiliary you can have either form ‘a‘ contact (a.k.a. 52a per ANSI) or form ‘b‘ (a.k.a. 52b).
A form ‘a‘ contact represents a Normally Open (N.O.) contact. Thus when the breaker is open, its 52a contacts are open. When the breaker is closed, the 52a contacts are closed. The 52a contact follows the status of the breaker.
A form ‘b‘ contact represents a Normally Closed (N.C.) contact. It operates exactly opposite of what an ‘a’ does. When the breaker is open, the 52b contacts are closed. When the breaker is closed, the 52b contacts are open.
Apart from breaker auxiliary switch contacts, you will see relays such as anti-pump relay 52Y, low gas relay 63X, under voltage relay 27 etc in the breaker scheme. The contacts from each of these relays are interlocked with other relays (including 52a-52b) in such a way that they either permit or not permit the breaker operation.
Circuit Breaker Trip Scheme
For the trip circuit you must wire the tripping relays’ ‘a’ contact in parallel. See Figure 2. Therefore when any one relay or switch contact closes, thus completing the circuit, the breaker trips. Only exception to the parallel wiring of contacts is the low-gas auxiliary relay contact (63X in the figure). This one is wired in series. Why?
Modern power circuit breakers employ Sulfur Hexa-Flouride (SF6) gas to extinguish an arc. Without adequate gas i.e. reduced interrupting capability, a flash-over can occur inside the tank. To prevent flash-overs due to low gas, breakers are fitted with ANSI ’63’ relay. Tripping of breaker is cut out by this relay’s contact.
Most modern circuit breakers are specified with two trip coils. Energizing either one trips the breaker. Since a good amount of redundancy is built into the protection and control of a power system, it is not uncommon to see all primary relaying in the system tripping trip coil 1 and the back-up tripping trip coil 2.
At this point, I hope the reader has grasped the strategy of series-parallel placement of relay contacts.
Let’s look at other relays and switches from the trip circuit of our breaker. The 27B under-voltage relay trip coil is connected across the same DC source as the one feeding the trip circuit. When this supply is interrupted, the 27B relay coil is de-energized, operating its contacts. In our breaker we are not blocking trip for this abnormal condition. It is typical in the industry to only annunciate locally and forward the alarm to a remote operator via SCADA. The breaker is also fitted with a 43 switch that toggles between local trip and remote trip. Positioning it in local allows the persons at the breaker junction box to trip the breaker by closing the Control Switch (CS). Switching it to remote position permits the relays in the control house to trip the breaker.
Target lamps are used in circuits to convey certain conditions. With the breaker closed and energized, the red lamp illuminates to indicate a live breaker. When the breaker opens the green lamp illuminates – the circuit complete with 52b contact switching from open to close.
Now, you may notice the red target lamp is connected in a way that will essentially short out the tripping relays and trip the breaker. Not surprisingly, this is not the case. The target lamps shown in the scheme have enough resistance in them (~200 ohms for a 125VDC circuit), limiting the current that can energize the coil.
Circuit Breaker Close Scheme
For this circuit you must wire breaker control relay’s ‘a’ contact in series with a string of 86 lockout relay ‘b’ contacts before you hit the anti-pump relay in the close circuit. Why? Well, would you want to close a breaker into a faulted circuit? See figure 3. In this example you have 86T (transformer LOR) and 86B (bus LOR) ‘b’ contacts in series with ‘a’ contact of SEL351S breaker control relay. Therefore when either a transformer or a bus fault occurs, its corresponding LOR will block the SEL351S from completing the circuit.
Modern breaker control relays are programmed to check for synchronism. That is, before the breaker is closed, the relay checks the phase angle of source and load side voltage of any one phase. If the angles are out of sync, the relay logic will not allow its close control contact to operate.
The close circuit also has contacts from the Motor Switch (MS). The motor is used to charge the spring that trips-closes. The motor switch contacts don’t allow the breaker to close until it finishes it job.
To prevent inadvertent multiple closing operation, breakers are fitted with anti-pump relay (52Y ANSI designation). Assume a scenario where a fault persists on a line and a person is attempting to close a breaker on it. Although the person presses the close button for a second or two, for the breaker which operates in cycles, this duration is an eternity. With the close button pressed, the breaker attempts to open and close multiple times. Since the motor in the breaker is not rated for continuous duty, serious damage can occur.
On a final note, keep in mind that not all relays back in the control building can handle the momentary inrush current from the breaker. Case-in-point the SCADA control relays. Interposing relays like those manufactured by Potter-Brumfield are typically installed to act as the middle-man. So in our case the SCADA relay trips an interposing relay and this relay trips the breaker.
Most modern microprocessor relays especially ones made by Schweitzer can handle inrush currents upto 30Amps and thus can be wired directly to the breaker coils.
- Breaker scheme is a web of interlocked relays and switches.
- Breaker operation is controlled by relays and switches.
- Trip contacts are wired in parallel.
- Close contacts are wired in series i.e. breaker control relay ‘a’ contact followed by a series of LOR ‘b’ contacts.